Warning: The contents of this post may not be up to date!
Sorry, but if you’re searching for answers about why you can’t reliably set environment variables in OS X (particularly
PATH), the information below may be out of date.
Apple has changed the system so many times in so many different ways it’s difficult to find anything on the internet about this that is correct and up-to-date, so I’ve placed this warning on the top of every post I’ve written about it.
As of 2017-03-02 it appears that the best collection of information is the osx-env-sync project on GitHub and its associated issues.
Be wary of anything that you find on StackOverflow: the answers there may well have been correct at the time but incorrect now.
For reference, my own posts on this problem (newest first) are:
When I was writing the script in yesterday’s post I came across this bizarre text encoding problem:
UnicodeDecodeError: 'ascii' codec can't decode byte 0xe2 in position 5: ordinal not in range(128)
Ascii what? We’re all Unicode now, don’t you know? If I’m taking in UTF-8 text, keeping it in a Unicode string, and then writing it out to UTF-8 encoded text files where is goddamn Ascii creeping in?
This first occurred at work, while I was trying to work, so my horrendous hack solution was to switch the temporary files into binary mode and encode the two strings into UTF-8 before writing them out. (This was when the script was still a text filter, so the problem was only on the back end.)
That’s a horrible hack. Bytes! Yuck! So in my next attempt I explicitly opened the files with a UTF-8 encoding. Which was still gross. And totally unnecessary. This is Python 3, everything’s Unicode, all the defaults are UTF-8, why am I having to specify the encoding at every point?
This was the point at which I found a relevant Stack Overflow question. Unfortunately the answer there was to tinker with Python’s start-up files in a way that was always discouraged and had since been removed from Python 3.
Hm. But what’s this about
sys.setdefaultencoding? So I started poking around with this terrible little script:
#!/usr/bin/env python3 import os import sys import locale entire_file = open(os.environ['BB_DOC_PATH'], 'r') print(os.environ) print(entire_file.encoding) print(sys.getdefaultencoding()) print(locale.getpreferredencoding())
For the last three lines, which print the encodings used, I got:
US-ASCII # File encoding utf-8 # sys.getdefaultencoding US-ASCII # locale.getpreferredencoding
So the system setting wasn’t the culprit. But why is the system encoding different to the locale, which seems to determine the default encoding with which files are opened?
Locale refers to the environment variables in my Terminal, but when I try
echo $LANG it’s set to
en_GB.UTF-8 — surely that’s not the problem?
As this thread eventually made me realise, I didn’t actually have
$LANG set to anything — it was all smoke and mirrors that cleared away when I ran the script through BBEdit. (I also had a similar problem with Applescript’s
do shell script and it looks like Sublime Text users have also run into it.) Checking the
os.environ output from the script above confirmed it: no
The root of the problem is that if a locale isn’t set it defaults to the C locale — meaning US-ASCII in OS X. The solution is to explicitly set $LANG in your .bash_profile:
I’ve also got that line in ~/.bashrc for safety, but do bear in mind that some shells will ignore both ~/.bash_profile and ~/.bashrc.
You could set the other
LC_* keywords as well, if you like, but
$LANG should be enough according to the man page for
LANG Used as a substitute for any unset LC_* variable. If LANG is unset, it will act as if set to "C". If any of LANG or LC_* are set to invalid values, locale acts as if they are all unset.
I’ve just re-watched Ned Batchelder’s great Pragmatic Unicode video and while setting the
$LANG environment variable is a handy solution on your own machines, it’s not a good fit when you’re writing a program that will run on systems where you can’t control the default encoding.
In such cases it makes sense to adopt his “Unicode sandwich” approach of explicitly decoding I/O and then working on the resulting Unicode.